Psst… Co-Sleeping and Cry-It-Out Aren’t Your Only Choices!

Sleep expert Amy Wallace of Little Dreamers shares her tips on finding alternatives to cry-it-out and co-sleeping methods.

When it comes to addressing your baby’s sleep issues, the debate often seems polarised between two primary methods: Cry It Out (CIO) and co-sleeping. However, these are not the only options available to parents.

Many alternative approaches offer a more balanced and gentle way to help your baby sleep better without the stress associated with CIO or the constant proximity required by co-sleeping. Let’s explore some of these methods.

Read more: Mastering Daylight Savings in New Zealand: Your Ultimate Guide to a Smooth Transition

Alternatives to Cry-It-Out & Co-Sleeping:

Layering in Sleep Associations

This involves soothing your baby to sleep without letting them cry it out and reducing the reliance on that association. This might look like patting them whilst feeding to sleep, then patting in their cot and moving towards removing the patting so they’re relying more on parental presence and verbal support than physical touch. 

The Ferber Method (Graduated Extinction)

The Ferber Method is a middle ground between CIO and more gentle methods. It involves allowing your baby to cry for short, gradually increasing periods before offering comfort. This approach helps babies learn to self-soothe while ensuring they don’t feel abandoned. By responding to your baby at set intervals, you teach them that you are still there for them, but they need to start learning to fall asleep on their own.

Gradual Withdrawal Method

The Gradual Withdrawal Method, where you sit in a chair next to your baby’s cot/bed as they fall asleep, gradually moving the chair farther away over time. The Chair Method involves sitting in a chair next to your baby’s crib as they fall asleep. Over time, you gradually move the chair farther away until you’re out of the room entirely. This method provides a sense of security for your baby, as they can see and hear you, but it also encourages them to learn to sleep independently. It’s a slow but effective transition that minimises distress for both baby and the parents.

Routine and Environment Adjustments

Sometimes, sleep issues can be resolved by tweaking your baby’s bedtime routine or sleep environment. Ensure the room is dark, white noise, and warm enough. Establish a consistent and calming bedtime routine that signals it’s time to wind down. Avoid stimulating activities before bed and consider using white noise to create a soothing backdrop. Small changes in the environment can have a significant impact on your baby’s sleep quality.

Responsive Settling

Responsive settling involves observing your baby and responding to their needs in a way that helps them settle back to sleep without fully waking them up. This might mean patting them gently, shushing, or offering a pacifier. The goal is to provide comfort without fully picking them up, allowing them to learn to self-settle over time.

You Can Still Be an Attached Parent Without Bed-sharing

Choosing not to bed share doesn’t make you any less of an attached parent. Attachment parenting is about being responsive and attuned to your baby’s needs, and this can be achieved in various ways, including through different sleep arrangements. Whether you’re settling your little one to sleep in their own cot or using a gentle sleep-shaping method, your responsiveness and connection with your baby remain the core of your parenting approach.

Read more: Transitioning from Bed-Sharing: Helping Your Child Embrace Their Own Sleep Space

While CIO and co-sleeping are often the most discussed methods for managing baby sleep issues, they are not the only options. Gentle and gradual approaches can be equally effective in helping your baby develop healthy sleep habits without the stress of prolonged crying or the challenges of co-sleeping.

Every baby is unique, so it’s important to find the method that works best for your family. By exploring and combining different techniques, you can create a sleep plan that ensures restful nights for both your baby and yourself, all while maintaining a strong and responsive bond.

nook nz perk


Use the code NOOK10 for 10% off 1:1 consultation packages!

If you need some sleep support and you are ready to make a change our team of experts are here for you! Book a discovery call and let’s chat about your little one’s sleep and how we can help your family get the rest you all need to thrive.

Share this:

About the author

Picture of Amy Wallace

Amy Wallace

Amy, a mum of three is a certified Infant and Child Sleep Consultant and a member of the International Institute for Complementary Therapists. She is the founder of Little Dreamers and co-founder of Beyond Sleep School. Her approach is practical and result-driven, focusing on the big "why" and tailoring solutions to each family’s unique situation. Support, education and a parent-first approach to sleep and family wellness is at the heart of her coaching.

Related posts

Your Family-Friendly Guide to The Crossing: A Shopping Spot That Actually Works for Families

What’s On for Kids This Weekend: Whānau Day at The Piano, Kaiapoi Gypsy Fair and more

Why Selwyn’s New ReUse Shop Is Every Parent’s Secret to Saving Big

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Like what you see? We’d love to share even more with you! Sign up for our weekly newsletter where we’ll be clueing you in on the newest family finds, straight to your inbox.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Like what you see? We’d love to share even more with you! Sign up for our weekly newsletter where we’ll be clueing you in on the newest family finds, straight to your inbox.